This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may earn a small commission—thanks for your support!
It is true, however, that witch books always seem to appear when they are most needed. Perhaps it is the first crisp night of fall, and one needs something to wrap in along with the warmth of the hearth and the glow of the candle. Maybe it is the need to get away from boring romance novels and into some snark, broomsticks, and a spell that goes wrong.
On the other hand, it could be that one wishes for something dark and mysterious and about women who had their power buried deep underground for generations to discover. In any case, witchy books do not disappoint, but their popularity has risen to such heights that choosing the right one becomes a challenging task. Cozy spells in a small town, witch romance books with slow-burning magic, gothic sagas, and horrifying stories of witchcraft are all there on the same shelf. This guide will help sort out the 40 best witchy books by tropes and mood.
Witch Romance Books by Trope
A romance trope is what witch books are all about. It elevates the stakes, and the tropes are easy on the eyes.
Best Witch Books
Enemies to Lovers: Enemies with magic and a vendetta spark. Some examples of such enemies are the characters from Meet Cute Magic by Morgan Elizabeth, Go Hex Yourself by Jessica Clare, and Witcha Gonna Do? by Avery Flynn.
Second Chance: Those who enjoy the trope of second chances will surely appreciate The Ex Hex by Erin Sterling that takes place in a small town and is a good first choice for newcomers into the genre of witch romance novels.
Fake Dating: Not the Witch You Wed by April Asher and A Witch’s Guide to Fake Dating a Demon by Sarah Hawley are books with a fake relationship that turns serious fast.
Grumpy Sunshine: Love’s a Witch by Tricia O’Malley, Hexed Up by Hannah Haze, and The Witch Is Back by Sophie H. Morgan are novels about a couple with a grumpy scowler and a sunshine character.
Favorites and other Romcoms: In Hex Appeal by Kate Johnson, Spookily Yours by Jennifer Chipman, and Witch Please by Ann Aguirre, comedy comes first. The story Hot Hex Boyfriend by Carly Bloom includes the popular neighbors-to-lovers concept, whereas Bad Luck Charm by Julie Johnson is set in Salem, Massachusetts. The time travel element is included in An Ancient Witch’s Guide to Modern Dating by Cecilia Edward, while Payback’s a Witch by Lana Harper is a favorite among the LGBTQ community.
Cozy Witch Books for a Lazy Night In
Comfort is a key component of witch literature thanks to cozy fantasies, which provide comfort with low stakes and lots of charm.
“The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches” by Sangu Mandanna centers around found families and romantic love. “Disenchanted” by Lucy Jane Wood is an enchanted storybook novel, while “A Witch in Notting Hill” by Alexandra Paige relocates the magic to a London neighborhood.
Tee Harlowe’s “Potions & Prejudice” is a fantasy retelling of a traditional love story. “The Late-Night Witches” by Auralee Wallace is great to read during Halloween season. Closing out the cozy section are “The Modern Girl’s Guide to Magic” by Linsey Hall and “Impractical Magic” by Emily Grimoire, a small-town read for those with a taste for quirky characters and enchanting homes.
Books About Witches with a Bit of Mystery
If you want a bit of mystery to spice up your magic and spells, these witch books are a good fit.
Best Witchy Books
“The Magic We Made” by Meg Cabot is a mysterious book set in the world of witches. “Playing the Witch Card” by KJ Dell’Antonia and “Witch Hunt” by Cate Conte are good for those who love solving mysteries along with potions. Both Sharon Ibbotson’s “A Ghost’s Guide to Haunting a Witch” and Lindsay Lovise’s “Perfectly Wicked” are paranormal tales.
Dark and Literary Books About Witches
Not all witches are cute. These books cover power, history, family, and fear.
Witchy Romance Books
The famous witch novel of our day, “Practical Magic” by Alice Hoffman, tells the depressing tale of sisters and a village that speaks behind their backs. “The Witches of Cambridge” by Alice Hoffman continues with the atmospheric tone. “A Discovery of Witches” by Deborah Harkness is a long academic romance.
Try something sharper if you want that. Cackle by Rachel Harrison is a dark and humorous tale that takes place in an unusual little town. Additionally, Emilia Hart’s Weyward will take you on excursions with women across eras. Witchcraft for Wayward Girls by Grady Hendrix will keep you interested but unsettled. The Year of the Witching by Alexis Henderson creates a gloomy and claustrophobic setting.
The Last Witch and The Book of Witching by C. J. Cooke are stories about the past that cannot be forgotten. The Nature of Witches by Rachel Griffin is a young adult story about magical powers connected with the seasons. The Southern Sorority of Superstitious Witches by Katie Ortiz is fun and Southern.
How to Choose Your Next Witchy Book
Comfortable reading? Choose The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches.
Sparks of romance? Go Hex Yourself or The Ex Hex.
Humorous read? Grab Hex Appeal or Spookily Yours.
Spooky? Read Witchcraft for Wayward Girls.
Classical? You can always count on Practical Magic.
No matter if you are looking for the top witch novels for a rainy day, witch romantic fiction with lots of wit, or darker witch tales with historical background, there is a spell for you on the list. Just choose the right title and light a candle.